Although the initiation is complete, there is no time for a formal ceremony. Paladin Rahmani immediately tasks the probationary initiate, the Vault 76 dweller, to assist The Retreat with their local problem: A Blood Eagles gang under one Dagger.
The quest begins with travelling to the Retreat and locating Jennie Brown in the upper levels. She will be quite welcoming and suggest that the player talk to the other denizens of the Retreat in order to gather information about Dagger and her gang. There are three villagers to talk to spread out among the upper levels and each will offer a tidbit of information and some background on how Jennie Brown put the village together.
- One will mention that the Dagger's hideout is somewhere to the southwest and that they have been doing weekly "collections" of tribute from the village.
- Another will mention the raiders having access to special rocket launchers that could level the entire village.
- Finally, another will explain that Dagger has been causing traders to avoid the Retreat, cutting into the trading prospects.
After talking to them, speaking with Brown again will advance the quest. She will explain that she wants to preserve her tightly knit family and asks for Dagger and her crew to be wiped out. Dagger's Den is located to the southwest, beyond Berkeley Springs, with the entrance surrounded by improvised fortifications (which have to be navigated or jumped over with the Marsupial mutation or a jetpack). Inside, the first order of business is to wipe out the Blood Eagles in the caves and then gain access to the throne room. It is locked, but the key is just nearby, in one of the shacks overlooking the entrance in the eastern cave chamber.
Dagger will not attack at first, but she will immediately start dialogue once approached. She will threaten and boast, as usual, and it's perfectly possible to attack her immediately. She is flanked by a pair of her lieutenants, both armed with Gatling lasers, but little in the way of armor. Alternatively, the player can strike a deal with her and bribe her. In the first case, both the Brotherhood weapons cache and the Retreat's supplies can be recovered (a surviving lieutenant will attack upon exiting the throne room, clad in a power armor frame and random raider power armor pieces). In the latter, Dagger will give a Hellstorm missile launcher from her supplies and return the Retreat's supplies.
At this point, all that's left is returning to Jennie Brown and handing her the Retreat's supplies. It's also possible to give her a launcher from the Brotherhood's cache, although she does not ask for it. Once that's done, all that's left is returning to Paladin Rahmani to report back. She will be found in the middle of receiving a report from Knight Shin. The report will reveal that several crates marked with the Brotherhood's insignia fell into the hands of the Crater raiders. Shin will recommend immediate recovery, but Rahmani is cautious about openly attacking the raiders.
Their attitude when reporting back will depend on the choices. If the player opted to kill Dagger and the Blood Eagles, Rahmani will be concerned about the loss of life, but Shin will agree that it was the right choice. On the other hand, if the player chose to bargain, the paladin will receive the news with satisfaction, but Shin will be rather displeased. Finally, the question of Hellstorms: If the player chose to give Jennie a launcher, Rahmani will be cautiously optimistic that the villagers can now defend themselves, but Shin will be furious - due to reasons that will be made clear in due time. On the other hand, Shin will complement the player character's judgment if they choose to return the launchers, while Rahmani will express concern about the Retret's ability to defend itself without the weapons.
Either way, the next step is recovering the Brotherhood's property from the hands of raiders.
Behind the scenes
During One Wasteland For All, the quest existed in the game files under the name "Brothers in Arms."