Fallout Wiki
Advertisement
Fallout Wiki

Paladin Rahmani's actions are unbecoming of her station. She carelessly shares resources, takes unnecessary risks and doles out her trust to anyone who takes an interest in joining us, regardless of merit. The Brotherhood she's building is not the one I believe in.

Daniel Shin is a knight of the Brotherhood of Steel and the second-in-command to Paladin Rahmani of the Brotherhood First Expeditionary Force. The group was sent on a mission to re-establish contact with Elizabeth Taggerdy's Appalachian Brotherhood. Shin's Brotherhood comes from Lost Hills, California.

Shin holds the elders in high regard and is loyal to them. While he respects Rahmani's altruism, he dislikes her for not following the standards of the Brotherhood's strict codes and laws. Shin and Rahmani enter frequent arguments with each other.

Background

Knight Shin has been a driven and dedicated member of the Brotherhood for nearly 20 years.[2] He was recruited from the Mojave Wasteland around 2083, when a Brotherhood force under Knight Connors saved his home town from a raider attack.[3] Shin's uncommon valor during the defense earned him Connors' notice, a place within the Brotherhood's ranks, and a lifelong hatred of raiders and their ilk. His focus and commitment to the Brotherhood have drawn praise from the Council of Elders up to and including High Elder Roger Maxson.[4]

On the Brotherhood's expedition, they came across a town that was being threatened with massacre by Raiders who were stealing their supplies. Rahmani decided to stay and fight the Raiders, while Shin decided to arm ordinary civilians with weapons they found for protection against the Raiders, which violated the Brotherhood's protocol to safeguard them instead of distribute them. The Raiders were able to steal their weapons and slaughtered everyone in the town except for Marcia and Max Leone. Connors would save Shin once again at the cost of his life.[5] Since this incident, Shin has harbored great guilt and vowed to never let his emotions hamper his judgement, although Rahmani believed he needed to forgive himself as he was ultimately trying to help. This incident would set off a division between Rahmani and Shin, with Shin wanting himself and Rahmani to stand trial with the Council of Elders. Marcia blamed both Rahmani's and Shin's actions for the tragedy, feeling no one should have retaliated against the raiders in the first place.[6]

Shin's fierce devotion to the Brotherhood's ideals makes him an effective officer whose performance is exemplary. He is also single-minded with little patience for distractions or disagreements, especially from subordinates or non-members. He is particularly resistant to change and any challenges to the Brotherhood's authority or tenets, which is a point of contention between him and his superior, Paladin Rahmani. However, Shin will give credit where credit is due, appreciating a job well done and saying so, regardless of his personal opinion. Despite his cold exterior, Shin truly cares for the future of humanity, hoping that the Brotherhood can create a safe society going forward. Ultimately though, Shin says those ideals mean nothing if he cannot protect the people who believe in him.[7]

Valdez, Rahmani and Shin arrive at Fort ATLAS

On a day-to-day basis at Fort Atlas, Shin is in charge of the armory and its equipment. He also leads various combat operations, due to the low amount of senior officers at the fort. His occasionally unwelcoming attitude is a result of his steadfast commitment to both his responsibilities and the values of the Brotherhood, stating that his duties "do not include human resources."[8]

Over the course of their reinforcing of Fort Atlas and establishing themselves in the region, Shin and Rahmani came into multiple conflicts of personality through various matters, the most important of which is the resurgence of government rocket launchers and other weaponry, used in the same incident that Shin believes he and Rahmani should be taken back to Lost Hills and tried for. During a mission to re-establish contact with the Brotherhood in California by using a long-range transmitter, Rahmani tries to persuade the Vault Dweller to her side, asking them to destroy the transmitter with her to help create a Brotherhood she strives for, free from the control of the Elders. She reveals her intentions of severing ties with the main body of the Brotherhood of Steel and seeking to form her own, independent Appalachian Chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel.[9][10] Whether or not the Vault Dweller participates, Rahmani destroys it regardless, angering Shin who no longer deems her part of the Brotherhood. However, before they can continue debating any further, they receive word of a super mutant attack at Fort Atlas, which caused temporary need of unity from both Rahmani and Shin.[11] Back at the base, Rahmani's actions also shock Valdez, who is annoyed another issue has arose between Rahmani and Shin. The super mutant attack is dealt with.

Nevertheless, a year later in 2104, Rahmani and Shin are still at odds over their Brotherhood's primary mission: Protect the people in Appalachia, or secure all manner of pre-War tech to prevent it from causing another apocalypse like the Great War. They soon discover that the super mutant attack on Fort Atlas was not coincidental. Dr. Edgar Blackburn, one of the people who came to Fort Atlas earlier looking for help from the Brotherhood, only to be turned away by Shin, had been kidnapping people from all over Appalachia to use as test subjects in his research to improve the Forced Evolutionary Virus.

Shin, along with initiates Erika Hewsen and Norland, decide to investigate the Uncanny Caverns after hearing the super mutants may be originating from there. Norland ends up being killed after the group separates and Shin blames himself for the death of someone else again. As they venture further into the cavern, Hewsen ends up becoming caught in an explosive trap and Shin tries to rescue her in his power armor, injuring himself. With Hewsen's aid, they eventually return to Fort Atlas.

Later, Rahmani learns that Blackburn was among several of the Blue Ridge's caravans, especially one that holed up in the Harpers Ferry tunnel due to a radstorm. After Blackburn was captured during his work inside Vault 96, Rahmani and Shin take him to the West Tek research center, where his fellow scientists Farha, Jain and Nellie Wright were putting the final touches on the FEV to release into the water and air, which would lead to more people being turned into super mutants once exposed, a worst-case scenario even worse than Huntersville. In a bid to prove their research is for the betterment of humanity in the wasteland, Blackburn willingly volunteers to be exposed to the virus himself, but a miscalculation or malfunction in the process causes Blackburn to be turned into a violent super mutant behemoth, forcing Rahmani and Shin to kill him.

After, Shin erupts at Rahmani, scolding her that something like this was just what the elders wanted to prevent: People trying to play God with science. Though Rahmani agrees with him on that, when they confront Farha, Jain and Nellie, they plead for mercy and ask that their lives be spared, considering that their research is invaluable to the wasteland with the loss of schools and universities because of the Great War and the decay that followed. Though Rahmani wants to spare them because of how valuable human life is nowadays, Shin is adamant that they be slain after seeing firsthand just how dangerous their knowledge is should it fall into the wrong hands if they are allowed to live. In the end, the conflict over Blackburn's associates results in Rahmani and Shin parting ways, unable to reach an agreement, with one either being killed or allowed to return to Maxson, while the other takes command of the Brotherhood to lead them on their new duty to Appalachia.

Interactions with the player character

Interactions overview

Interactions
Icon interactions essential.webp
This character cannot be killed. Status expires when The Catalyst begins.
25 Strictly Business.png
This character is a temporary companion.
FO76 ui icon quest.png
This character is involved in quests.

Quests

  • Forging Trust: Knight Shin represents the first step towards service in the Brotherhood for the Vault 76 dwellers, and asks them to handle several requests from "civilian" visitors at Fort Atlas.
  • Property Rights: After completing their initiation, the dwellers assist Shin in recovering Brotherhood property from the Crater raiders.
  • Over and Out: Shin and Rahmani appear at the end of the quest at the Enclave research facility, where their conflict boils over and the dwellers must choose to side with one of the two.
  • The Best Defense: Immediately after the previous quest, Shin and Rahmani are temporarily united against a common enemy, defending Fort Atlas against a super mutant attack alongside the dwellers.
  • A Knight's Penance: The Vault Dweller, Shin, Norland and Erika Hewsen investigate the Uncanny Caverns after learning that the super mutants may be originating from within.
  • The Catalyst: Shin becomes involved with the source of the chaos.

Other interactions

  • If the player has allied with the Raiders, Shin can be informed during Property Rights during the questioning with Pierce. Once Pierce is dealt with, Shin will confront the Vault Dweller, interrogating them about their relationship with Crater. The responses result in a stern talking to from Shin or Shin thinking the Vault Dweller is just trying to be humorous. At Fort Atlas, there is another Raider option while talking to Shin in which the Vault Dweller calls the Raiders pretty cool. Shin calls them foul, violent and shameless and says it is not a funny joke.
  • If the player talks to Shin after Property Rights, Shin calls Pierce a "vile" man and says Pierce's "family" are a criminal mob. Shin then says that the way Pierce tries to "twist his words" to justify himself is repulsive.
  • If the player sides with Rahmani, Shin can be killed in combat by Rahmani and the Vault Dweller. If he is not attacked, Shin plans on walking across the country back to California with the Initiates he can trust in order to tell the elders all the events that have transpired. He disappears from the game's world and it is unknown what becomes of Shin's journey.

Inventory

Notes

Bethesda revealed that the majority of players side with Rahmani over Shin, showing results where 82% of players chose Rahmani and 18% chose Shin.[Non-canon 1]

Notable quotes

  • "If we accept you as an Initiate - and that is far from certain - you would be pledging yourself to our order and our cause. Our order exists to locate, secure, and protect dangerous technologies. Humanity cannot be trusted with the means to destroy itself. We will not allow another apocalypse."
  • "It sounds to me like you haven't decided your purpose in this world. I have, and it doesn't involve making friends with everyone."
  • "Everything I do is for the good of humanity. I want to create a safe society again... to live and work side by side, as it should be. But those ideals are for nothing if I can't protect the people who believe in me. I have to do right by them."
  • "On that point we agree. I refuse to serve an illegitimate branch of a principled institution. The Elders need to know about our failures. All of them. It will be my honor to give that report in person."
  • "I... For those I failed then, and those I've failed since... For them, I have to do better. The raiders on the expedition route. Rahmani decided we would stay and fight them. But giving the order to distribute the weapons to the settlers there... It was my idea. I wanted to give them a chance, but I got them killed instead."
  • "We're not a charity. We're protectors. Sometimes we have to do things that are difficult in the best interests of everyone else. Carry out the sentence. They're murderers. Make sure they can never kill again."
  • "Rahmani was a reckless commander, a stubborn diplomat, and a traitor. She was also my closest ally. For all we disagreed upon, no one else shared my dedication to a brighter future. Not like Rahmani did. Though she's not with us now, I will forever carry the valor and determination she impressed upon me."
  • "Rahmani put her personal morals above the cornerstone of duty time and time again. Her irresponsibility threatened to shake apart the foundation of order that allows us to be an effective force of action. But however misguided her decisions were, Rahmani always acted with the intent to help humanity. If we are to retain anything from her leadership, let it be that. The Brotherhood of Steel seeks to forge a lasting future. We must be humanity's strength. Strength to eliminate threats, overt and covert. Strength to keep dangerous technology safe. Strength to make the decisions that no one else wants to make. We are humanity's rock, standing against the harsh enemies of war, disease, and time. We must not falter. Ad victoriam!"
  • "That comment was unprofessional. Though... I think I'll choose not to reprimand you for it just yet. Just don't get too affectionate near the Initiates. I can't have them thinking I'm playing favorites." – Shin's response to being flirted with

Appearances

Daniel Shin appears only in Fallout 76, introduced in the Steel Dawn update and expanded upon in the Steel Reign update.

Behind the scenes

  • Although never mentioned in-game, design director Mark Tucker stated that as a child, Shin grew up in a very rigidly structured household on the West Coast as the only son of a school principal.[Non-canon 2]
  • When asked if Shin's design took inspiration from other Brotherhood characters, quest designer Ellys Tan jokingly said "Shin was inspired by my perception of a hot tsundere Brotherhood knight."[Non-canon 3]
  • For unknown reasons, Shin looks quite a bit older in promotional art with more pronounced nasal folds and thicker upper lips. His in-game model also looks considerably less Asian than his promotional art, as Shin is a Korean family name.

Gallery

Artwork

References

  1. Vault Dweller: "Can I join the Brotherhood?"
    Paladin Rahmani: "I'm glad that you are inspired by our mission! In order to fully accomplish our goals and establish a foothold here in Appalachia, we need to build up our ranks. If you're interested in recruitment, you can speak with my second, Knight Shin."
    (Leila Rahmani's dialogue)
  2. Vault Dweller: "[Charisma 8+] I work better by getting to know my leadership."
    Knight Shin: "I don't understand how that works, but I'll take your word for it. I've been with the Brotherhood for almost 20 years. I consider my life before that irrelevant. I think our mission is the only hope for humanity in the long-term. And I think that any time I don't spend on that mission is irresponsible. There. Are you able to work now?"
    (Daniel Shin's dialogue)
  3. Leila Rahmani: "The Brotherhood saved Shin's hometown from a Raider attack. It was then that Knight Connors recruited him into the fold."
    (Leila Rahmani's dialogue)
  4. Fort Atlas terminal entries; Scribe Valdez's terminal, KNIGHT Shin, Daniel
  5. Vault Dweller: "The Raiders mentioned a Knight's helmet. Did someone important die?"
    Knight Shin: "A Knight's helmet? It must be... Two other Knights embarked with us from the West Coast. Knight Thornberry returned partway through the journey. Knight Connors gave his life in honorable service to the Brotherhood. Show the proper respect when asking about him. To think they held on to his helmet like a trophy... It's unforgivable."
    (Daniel Shin's dialogue)
  6. Marcia's diary
  7. Vault Dweller: "I still believe in you, Knight."
    Knight Shin: "Everything I do is for the good of humanity. I want to create a safe society again... to live and work side by side, as it should be. But those ideals are for nothing if I can't protect the people who believe in me. I have to do right by them."
    (Daniel Shin's dialogue)
  8. Vault Dweller: "What do you do here?"
    Knight Shin: "As you can see, I'm in charge of the armory. I maintain and manage all of our equipment. I keep records of our stockpiles, distribute rations, and acquire resources as needed. Since we only have one Paladin here, I also lead various combat operations and support Paladin Rahmani in any ways necessary. To be clear, my duties do not include human resources."
    (Daniel Shin's dialogue)
  9. Paladin Rahmani: "I destroyed the transmitter. The Elders are blind to the good we can do. We need to break free from their influence."
    (Leila Rahmani's dialogue)
  10. Fort Atlas terminal entries; Paladin Rahmani's terminal, Our Future in Appalachia
  11. Knight Shin: "Rahmani and I are both putting our full efforts into understanding the extent of the Super Mutant threat. Once that's dealt with, we'll have her betrayal to contend with. It may be some time before that happens."
    (Daniel Shin's dialogue)

Non-canon

  1. Bethesda: Fallout 76: Inside the Vault – Anniversary Stats, Limited Preview & More!
  2. Fallout 76 – Steel Dawn (Developer Gameplay)
    Mark Tucker: "For example, Daniel Shin is the, uh, son of a principal, and he's, you know, he's from the west coast and, you know, he grew up the only son of a principal in a very structured home, you know, and when you meet Daniel in the game, you'll see that."
  3. Bethesda Game Studio's official Discord:
    "3. Shin was inspired by my perception of a hot tsundere Brotherhood knight"
Antagonists
Advertisement